The versatile German left teammate Rob Holding stunned by his touch and volley technique at Audi Field.
Havertz, Marquinhos and Holding were Arsenal's team of three, where they competed against the MLS trio of Thiago Almada, Hector Herrera and Hany Mukhtar.
Arsenal and the MLS All-Stars competed in the Skill Challenge on Wednesday - a day prior to their meeting on the football pitch.
Prior to the touch drill, Arsenal beat the MLS team in the shooting challenge - thanks to Jurrien Timber, Jakub Kiwior and Folarin Balogun.
And the north Londoners then went 2-0 up, with Havertz proving to be the star of the show.
READ MORE ON ARSENAL
Folarin Balogun outshined by Jurrien Timber and Jakub Kiwior in shooting challenge
Arsenal transfer news LIVE: Arteta hints at more business, Inter set to move for Balogun
The drill consisted of three people, two of which sprayed passes into the player in the middle, who had two touches to direct the ball into a zone.
Players got 90 seconds to score as many points as they could, with zones consisting of 20, ten, five, and two-point values.
The last five balls were fired in from behind the goal, with scores doubling if the player got the ball into one of the targets.
Marquinhos and Havertz were elected by Arsenal to take centre stage, with the Brazilian winger scoring a respectable 53 points.
Most read in Football
Onana to Man United, Rashford new deal while Evans re-signs, Chelsea fail in Caicedo bid
Joao Felix channels inner Romelu Lukaku by sending come and get me plea to Barcelona
Rangers 1-2 Newcastle LIVE: Ashby wins it late for Magpies as Howe's men seal victory
Three Bayern stars, including Musiala, score five goals as no mercy shown to local team
Havertz then closed the show with a whopping 86 points, with Holding racing up to him following the challenge in disbelief by his technique.
Even Havertz looked impressed by his score, as he walked off with a huge grin on his face.
Though he was left feeling rather embarrassed in the next event after he failed to score a single goal in the cross and volley drill.