Coventry were 1-0 down against Millwall and won a spot-kick to get back on level terms.
However, Wright and O'Hare had a debate over who was going to take it and had to settle it with a game of rock, paper, scissors.
Wright won and duly converted the penalty before adding a second just minutes later.
Thankfully he did as manager Mark Robins would have been furious with them.
After the match, Robins gave his own thoughts on the rock, paper, scissors…
Read more on Championship
Bamford scores 'Maradona' handball goal as Rotherham call out 'unprofessional' officials
West Brom star forced off in tears as gut-wrenching injury record strikes again
He told talkSPORT: "I'm going to kill them - Rock, paper, scissors to decide a penalty taker!
"Haji's taken penalties, Callum had one and scored his last one. Haji's a penalty taker regularly in Turkey, so I had no problem with that. It's just the outcome of it, you want that to be a decisive action.
"Thankfully he was clear in his brain once he'd become clear on that, but I will have a chat with them about that."
Wright was prolific in the Turkish Super Lig with Antalyaspor before moving to the Championship side last summer.
Most read in Football
Real Madrid deliver downbeat Bellingham injury news ahead of huge Champions League tie
Carlo Ancelotti reckons there is one player in the world better than Jude Bellingham
Thomas Muller gives X-rated interview as he calls out Bayern Munich teammates
German media give brutal analysis of Harry Kane's performance in Bayer Leverkusen defeat
Robins' side are looking to get back into the play-offs this season after suffering heartbreak in the final last year.
They are currently in sixth place, clinging onto the final play-off spot by goal difference.