Loophole reason why Fernandez escaped FA ban over racist chant but not Bentancur

talksport.com, 18 November 2024, 14:59
Rodrigo Bentancur will serve a seven-match ban for making a racial slur but Enzo Fernandez escaped an FA ban for a similar incident.

The Tottenham midfielder cannot play domestic football until Boxing Day yet his fellow South American has gone unpunished.

Bentancur, who has also been handed a £100,000 fine, was filmed on Uruguayan TV making derogatory remarks about South Koreans in a reply to a question about Spurs captain Son Heung-min.

Chelsea rival Fernandez meanwhile has been free to play since footage of his racist chant went viral due to a strange loophole.

The Argentine filmed himself singing a derogatory chant in the aftermath of his country's Copa America win earlier this year.

The song refers to how many French national team players are of African heritage, with the lyrics translating to: "They play for France, but their parents are from Angola. Their mother is from Cameroon, while their father is from Nigeria. But their passport says French."

Read more on Premier League

Rodrigo Bentancur handed lengthy ban and will miss Tottenham's nightmare fixture run

Ex-Premier League manager dumbfounded by Deeney's claim that Salah isn't world class

It led to his Chelsea teammate Wesley Fofana publicly calling out Fernandez and describing the song as, 'uninhibited racism.'

The midfielder quickly apologised, as Son confirmed Bentancur had also done, but Fernandez avoided a Premier League ban.

Why won't the FA charge Fernandez?

Simply, it comes down to jurisdiction, as when Fernandez was on international duty when he sang a racist chant.

So, the FA handed the responsibility of a potential punishment to FIFA and/or CONMEBOL to hand down any sanctions.

Most read in Football

Harry Kane statue hidden away for five years finally unveiled - and fans are in disbelief

England legend 'bewildered' by Thomas Tuchel holiday decision

Rodrigo Bentancur handed lengthy ban and will miss Tottenham's nightmare fixture run

Arsenal hit with fresh injury headache as star man forced off during international game

Months later, Fernandez is still freely playing for Argentina, with news of any investigation going cold and unlikely to materialise.

Even if the matter is revisited and disciplinary action is retroactively taken, it would only apply to international games and not Chelsea.

So why is Bentancur different?

Bentancur's offence took place on Uruguayan TV in June, weeks after Tottenham's 2023/24 Premier League season had ended.

However, the ex-Juventus star hadn't officially been released by Spurs for Copa America duty and so it remains a Premier League matter.

Bentancur interviewed with Cotelo in his own time, which meant the FA saw fit to charge him for his comments.

An FA statement read: "An independent Regulatory Commission has imposed a seven-match suspension and £100,000 fine on Rodrigo Bentancur for a breach of FA Rule E3 in relation to a media interview.

"It was alleged that the Tottenham Hotspur midfielder breached FA Rule E3.1 as he acted in an improper manner and/or used abusive and/or insulting words and/or brought the game into disrepute. It was further alleged that this constitutes an "aggravated breach", which is defined in FA Rule E3.2, as it included a reference - whether express or implied - to nationality and/or race and/or ethnic origin.

"Rodrigo Bentancur denied this charge, but the independent Regulatory Commission found it to be proven and imposed his sanctions following a hearing. Its written reasons for these decisions can be seen below."

There is also a precedent behind the FA's decision-making, with Manchester City star Rodri avoiding domestic retribution for his Gibraltar remarks this summer.

The Ballon d'Or winner was handed a one-game ban by UEFA alongside Alvaro Morata for violating rules of 'decent conduct' by singing about Gibraltar in the aftermath of Spain's 2-1 win over England in the Euro 2024 final.

Tottenham captain Heung-Min Son reveals teammate Rodrigo Bentancur cried after apologising to him following racism scandal

What has been said?

Simon Jordan has highlighted why Fernandez escaped the kind of punishment that has left Tottenham reeling over Bentancur.

"Fernandez said something equally as challenging at Chelsea but he gets away with it because of jurisdiction rules," he said.

Read More on talkSPORT

Keane has Wright in stitches after future son-in-law Harwood-Bellis scores against Ireland

Mike Tyson 'almost died' before Jake Paul fight as he says 'I lost half my blood'

"So you've got an inconsistency about the manner in which you approach these things because the FA couldn't sanction Fernandez.

"He's playing in the FA's Premier League, but because he was playing out of their jurisdiction as released by Chelsea he was under the jurisdiction of another governance."

Top News

27 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Brighton vs. Brentford (Friday, 7.30pm) Brighton & Hove Albion welcome Brentford to the Amex in one of two games being played after Boxing Day in the Premier League. 27 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Arsenal have reportedly shortlisted 22-year-old Boca Juniors goalkeeper Leandro Brey as a transfer target for the January 2025 window. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Ruben Amorim has suffered the worst start of a Manchester United manager in 92 years thanks to Thursday's disheartening 2-0 Premier League loss to Wolverhampton Wanderers. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Chelsea suffered their worst Premier League collapse of the 2000s in their shock 2-1 home loss to Fulham at Stamford Bridge on Boxing Day. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk AVS and Estrela Amadora are in action for the last time in 2024 when they go head to head at the Estadio do Desportivo das Aves in round 16 of the Portuguese Primeira Liga on Saturday. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Liverpool wing wizard Mohamed Salah hit yet another Premier League goalscoring landmark as Arne Slot's league leaders fought back to defeat Leicester City 3-1 on Boxing Day. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Liverpool have moved seven points clear at the top of the Premier League table courtesy of a 3-1 victory over Leicester City at Anfield on Boxing Day. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Liverpool have lost key midfielder Dominik Szoboszlai to suspension for their trip to West Ham United in the Premier League this weekend. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk The only team in the Premier League with their unbeaten home record still intact, Arsenal seek to avoid a festive giant killing in Friday's Emirates encounter with Ipswich Town. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk The agent of Manchester United attacker Antony has confirmed that there is "concrete interest" in the Brazilian ahead of the January transfer window. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Tottenham Hotspur's defensive crisis worsened in their 1-0 Premier League loss to Nottingham Forest on Boxing Day, as Djed Spence was sent off while Radu Dragusin sustained an ankle injury. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Aiming to end 2024 on top of Serie A, league leaders Atalanta BC will tackle close challengers Lazio at Stadio Olimpico on Saturday evening. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Chelsea hotshot Cole Palmer broke a 23-year-old club goalscoring record set by Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink in the Blues' shock 2-1 Premier League defeat to West London derby rivals Fulham at Stamford Bridge. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Julen Lopetegui's West Ham United beat Southampton 1-0 away from home on Thursday afternoon and spoiled Saints manager Ivan Juric's first game in charge of the club. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Nottingham Forest have shot back into third place in the Premier League table thanks to Nuno Espirito Santo masterminding a 1-0 win over former club Tottenham Hotspur. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Andoni Iraola's Champions League hopefuls Bournemouth were held to a 0-0 draw away from home by Crystal Palace on Boxing Day at the Vitality Stadium in the Premier League. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Rodrigo Muniz scored a last-gasp winner as Fulham sensationally came from behind to defeat West London rivals Chelsea 2-1 at Stamford Bridge. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Aiming to arrest their underwhelming Primeira Liga results before Christmas, Estoril Praia and Moreirense clash at Estadio Antonio Coimbra da Mota on Saturday, keen to notch important victories in the gameweek 16 encounter. 26 December 2024 talksport.com Birmingham's Boxing Day clash with Burton had to be temporarily suspended due to a medical emergency at St Andrew's. 26 December 2024 talksport.com Kevin De Bruyne certainly wasn't in the festive spirit after walking down the tunnel immediately after Manchester City were held to a 1-1 draw against Everton. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Jose Mourinho reportedly wants Manchester United forward Marcus Rashford at Fenerbahce, while Paris Saint-Germain will not sign the 27-year-old. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Erling Haaland missed a second-half penalty as Manchester City's Premier League plight continued with a 1-1 draw at home to a dogged Everton unit at the Etihad Stadium. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Primeira Liga title contenders Porto could climb to first place on Saturday when they host relegation-threatened Boavista at Estadio do Dragao in gameweek 16. 26 December 2024 talksport.com Goalkeepers tend to be a little crazy and Jordan Pickford is no different. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Chelsea and Fulham have announced their teams for the West London derby at Stamford Bridge on Boxing Day. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Manchester United are paying increased attention to Atalanta BC midfielder Ederson ahead of a potential summer move to Old Trafford. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Arsenal pair Gabriel Jesus and David Raya could both write new chapters of Gunners history when Mikel Arteta's men host Ipswich Town in Friday's Premier League encounter. 26 December 2024 talksport.com Christmas may have come and gone, but Man City' boss Pep Guardiola - and his players - are hoping for presents in the form of new signings. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Aiming to finish a successful year with a streak of five straight Serie A wins, Inter Milan will visit Cagliari on Saturday, as both sides play their final fixture of 2024. 26 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Arsenal, Tottenham Hotspur and Chelsea are supposedly all prepared to go head-to-head for the services of Club Brugge defender Maxim De Cuyper in the January window.