Spurs fans threw paper from a pre-match display in the stands at Chelsea players during the clash, causing small delays in the game - but their efforts to distract their opponents were in vain.
Despite Tottenham going 2-0 up inside 12 minutes after a breathless start, Chelsea won the London derby 4-3.
And of course, ex-Blues player Cundy grasped the chance to rinse his Spurs supporting co-host after the Sports Bar derby.
Coming on air on Monday night, Cundy began the show with one of his best 'has anyone seen' outbursts yet.
AJ Tracey and Chick-King caught a few strays along the way, and O'Hara was left with his head in his hands.
more premier league
West Ham boss Lopetegui gets potentially job-saving win as O'Neil left on the brink
David Coote sacked by PGMOL after damaging videos and messages about referee leaked
The tormenting wasn't over there though.
Cundy then began chucking paper in the studio at O'Hara, just like the Spurs fans did to Chelsea players on Sunday.
The former Spurs midfielder tried to fight it at first but soon gave up.
"To dare is to do, who is responsible for that?!" Cundy laughed as the pair began analysing the performance.
Most read in Football
Former Premier League boss forced to learn to walk again after 'neurological situation'
Paolo Di Canio could have joined Man United and Roy Keane backed it
Cristian Romero appears to aim dig at club chiefs in damning comments after Chelsea defeat
Man City's hearing into 115 charges concludes with decision expected soon
"What is going on? Basically, Spurs are Chelsea's punch bag.
"You're basically Punch Bag FC. Punch Bag FC, Jay! You're the biggest joke in football, you are.
"2-0 up, two gifts, and you can't even bring a point Jay! You got battered mate, tickled your tummy then went bang to the ribs."
He continued: "You are finding new ways to embarrass and disgrace the badge."
Spurs had gone 2-0 up through Dominic Solanke and Dejan Kulusevski after Marc Cucurella slipped in the build up to both goals.
Jadon Sancho soon hit back to half the deficit from range, before Cole Palmer fired twice and Enzo Fernandez also found the goal in the second half.
Heung-min Son's goal in the sixth minute of added time was merely the consolation in the end.
Spurs are now in the bottom half of the Premier League, sitting in 11th after one win in the last five.
Jamie O'Hara believes Daniel Levy will SACK Ange Postecoglou after Christmas
"No one cares about Chelsea mate, you're the most irrelevant football club," O'Hara hit back at Cundy.
He continued: "At the moment it's not going well with Ange [Postecoglou] and if he doesn't change his in-game management, his tactics, or his plan, he'll get the sack.
"It's as simple as that."