This is the view of former Germany and Arsenal goalkeeper Jens Lehmann, who believes his compatriot is wrong for the role. Instead, he told supporters to expect the heartbreak to continue despite the Football Association of hiring a manager used to winning things.
The wait is nearly over for Tuchel's first game as Three Lions boss as his side will face Albania in a 2026 World Cup qualifier on March 21, with a second match against Latvia three days later.
However, the German has come under criticism before he's even named his first England squad after reports emerged of his work from home arrangement.
Tuchel struck an agreement with the FA that allowed him to make regular visits back to Germany to see his two children.
But that may all soon be forgotten should the former Chelsea, PSG, Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund boss begin delivering early results and show early signs of a positive brand of football.
Read more football
Inside Morgan Gibbs-White's phone call with Thomas Tuchel that led to late England call up
England's £300m omitted XI boasting star with more goals than Rashford and Foden combined
Even if he leads England to victory over Albania and Latvia, some fans may be unconvinced given he is the first German to manage England and the first foreigner to coach the men's team since Italian Fabio Capello left in 2012.
Even some in Germany may have been disappointed with Tuchel taking the England role given the history between the nations, with former Leicester star and Germany international Robert Huth admitting he wouldn't approve of an English manager being in charge of Germany.
However, Lehmann did not agree with Huth's verdict but insisted Tuchel was actually fortunate to land the role.
Lehmann also felt Huth was alone in believing Tuchel was a 'traitor'.
Most read in Football
Gravenberch injury scare, Palmer latest, Tuchel prepares for England bow
EFL club sack boss with nine games left in 'cruel' decision amid relegation fears
'No one cares' - Phil Jones' teammates brutally ignored his last message in players' chat
John Terry admits he wants to manage Chelsea but there's one reason it'll never happen
"For me, he is not a traitor," Lehmann clarified on talkSPORT Drive.
"For me, he is very lucky to get such a great job. There must be a reason why he's not with Bayern Munich anymore. It's very difficult to get sacked by Bayern Munich.
"But we are happy for him that he's the English coach now."
Yet despite Tuchel winning 11 trophies throughout his managerial career, including the Champions League, Lehmann believed he would not add to his haul as England boss.
"There's no such thing like being called a traitor," Lehmann said.
"I heard that for the first time from Robert. I like Robert and like sometimes his clear views.
"It doesn't make England more likely to win anything, but it's good for him."
talkSPORT Drive host Andy Goldstein immediately pressed Lehmann on why he felt England's trophy chances weren't boosted with Tuchel in charge given his previous success.
"You have to look at Bayern Munich and how they played last season," Lehmann said.
"Then you'll see it. If you understand football, you'll see it."
Under Tuchel, Bayern surrendered control of the Bundesliga title for the first time in 11 years as Xabi Alonso's Bayer Leverkusen went unbeaten to finish top of the table.
He departed the German giants at the end of the 2023/24 campaign as Bayern embarked on a 'sporting realignment', with former Burnley boss Vincent Kompany replacing him at the helm.
Tuchel's sole focus is now on delivering England's men their first trophy since 1966, but if Lehmann's prediction rings true, the wait will grow even longer.