The Brazilian born Italy international was looking unstoppable from 12 yards following his £50million move from Napoli to Chelsea in 2018, but that reputation came crashing down at Euro 2020.
Looking set to be the villain of the piece at Wembley in the final against England, Jorginho somehow survived a red card-looking challenge on Jack Grealish to be given the chance of winning the shootout.
Stepping up the 29-year-old saw his effort saved by Jordan Pickford, and despite Italy going on to win the tournament, Jorginho has since been at fault yet again in a high-pressure situation.
Facing Switzerland joint on points at the top of their World Cup qualifying group on Friday, the score was level at 1-1 heading into the final minutes, before Italy were gifted a last minute penalty.
Up stepped Jorginho with a chance to secure his nation's place at Qatar 2022, only for the Chelsea man to blast the spot-kick over the bar, leaving the European champion's World Cup spot still in the balance.
With Jorginho's penalty king reputation ebbing away, talkSPORT deemed it time to take a look at the best takers in the Premier League, to work out who is the real master from 12 yards.
You'd assume Bruno Fernandes' technique and Cristiano Ronaldo's return may see them top the charts, but neither of Manchester United's Portuguese duo make the top five according to Opta…
So there you have it, Mohamed Salah's run up and smash technique so far hasn't been worked out by opposition goalkeepers, with the Egyptian giving his opponent no time to guess where the ball is going.
It worked against Tottenham in Madrid to give Liverpool their sixth Champions League crown, and so far it's been near perfect in the Premier League.