Croatia
Indonesia
Nigeria
South Africa

Huge VAR change called for by ex-Premier League star after 'bad' Rico Lewis red

talksport.com, 7 December 2024, 19:10
A huge change to VAR rules has been called for after Manchester City saw Rico Lewis sent off against Crystal Palace.

The England international had scored a vital equaliser for the reigning Premier League champions in their 2-2 draw with the Eagles.

However, his joy quickly turned to frustration as he received a second yellow card for a tackle on Trevoh Chalobah.

Lewis went into the tackle hard and contact actually appeared to be from Chalobah on the versatile Man City star as they collided with the ball moved on by the ex-Chelsea star.

However, former Premier League players Jason Cundy, Scott Minto and Jamie O'Hara all felt the decision was harsh on Lewis.

And the referee's call led to ex-Chelsea star Cundy to call for a huge VAR change to improve the game.

read more on football

Michail Antonio in stable condition after car crash as West Ham send thoughts and prayers

Frank Lampard inflicts 116-year first on arch rivals in second Coventry match

He told talkSPORT: "The Rico Lewis second yellow card, I'm not having it mate. Okay. I'm not having it.

"I'll tell you what, if football really wants to move down the track of improving VAR - this has bugged me for a while - a second yellow card for a red, why it cannot be looked at by VAR?

"It is an absolute mystery."

O'Hara responded: "Well, you know my thoughts on VAR, Jason, I want it in the bin but I don't suppose it's going to happen."

Most read in Football

Andre Onana 'dives out of the way' of Morgan Gibbs-White strike in Man United collapse

Sir Jim Ratcliffe brands Man United 'mediocre' in bombshell interview

Frank Lampard inflicts 116-year first on arch rivals in second Coventry match

Michail Antonio in stable condition after car crash as West Ham send thoughts and prayers

Cundy replied: "No, no, VAR is here to stay, right? It's here to stay, right? But make it better. VAR is… Look, it ain't brilliant, it ain't perfect, but it's in the game and it's going to stay. Second yellow cards for a red have to be looked at by VAR.

"I don't understand how a straight red can be looked at, yet a second yellow for a red can't be. I don't get that.

"Improve the game. If VAR is here to stay, right, and it is, improve the game, make it better, make it work. Because for me, that second yellow, it's not a second yellow."

He later added: "The law is an a**.

"I don't fully understand what the difference would be in terms of what the decision is for that game. There is nothing to choose between the two. A second yellow changes the game, a straight red changes the game, right?

"So you can review a straight red, we've seen that happen. There was a second yellow a couple of weeks ago, I can't remember which one it was, it was harsh. But because you can't review it, you have to go with the on-field decision.

"Rico Lewis's yellow card today is an absolute disgrace. An absolute disgrace. There is no way on this earth it's even a foul, let alone a second yellow, right?

"Rob Jones gives it as a second yellow, fine, he makes mistakes. You can see why he's giving, right?

"When Chalobah wins the ball and then he steps on Rico Lewis's foot. If you're going to give any decision, you give it the Palace.

"The truth is, it's a non-decision. It's a non-decision for me.

The referee has seen Chalobah go down, but anyway, it's irrelevant.

"It's so bad. It's such a bad call. And then you find yourself in a position where for the last 20 minutes of the game, Man City are down to 10 men, but they now don't have Rico Lewis to choose, right?

"It's the second yellow, so he misses the next game. That to me, makes the law an a**.

"Change it."

He added: "I'm not sure we can blame Premier League. I think IFAB need to look at that. That's the governing body."

Former Manchester City assistant reveals how the club 'accidentally' made a £35 MILLION bid for Lionel Messi

Meanwhile, Minto, who watched the game for talkSPORT, added: "I don't get it.

"Someone's getting sent off. A team's going down to 10 men. So why should you not be doubly sure? Although we're never quite even doubly sure with VAR.

"I think if he looked at it again, it's one of those where, to the letter of the law, if he really wants to, he could argue the case that he was off his feet. He didn't get the ball and therefore it's a yellow card.

"But I think anybody who's watching football on a regular basis will say, come on, come on, that's harsh. You don't need to make that particular call."

After the match, Man City boss Pep Guardiola was asked about the challenge.

However, he simply turned the question around and replied "Have you seen it?

Read More on talkSPORT

I couldn't stand arrogant Ibrahimovic and our fight forced him to leave club within days

Frank Warren thrilled as 'greatest boxing card ever' is confirmed featuring Daniel Dubois

"I didn't see it, you can tell me, I didn't see it yet."

When the reporter admitted he and others had felt it was harsh, Guardiola said: "It is what it is," before swiftly exiting before talkSPORT could query him on the game.

Top News

22 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Dundee Utd vs. Celtic (Sunday, 12.00pm) Celtic, looking to maintain their unbeaten run in the Scottish Premiership, will travel to Tannadice Park on Sunday afternoon to face Dundee United. 22 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Everton vs. Chelsea (Sunday, 2.00pm) Chelsea have the chance to go top of the Premier League for a brief time at least when they travel to Goodison Park to face Everton on Sunday. 22 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk South American giants Palmeiras have reportedly sent an 'initial proposal' to Fulham for midfielder Andreas Pereira. 22 December 2024 talksport.com Nuno Espirito Santo will rival Arne Slot to win the Premier League's Manager of the Year award. 22 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Barcelona want to sever ties with attacker Ansu Fati at the earliest opportunity in the January transfer window but the player is rebelling against a move, according to a report. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Bayern Munich winger Leroy Sane has confirmed that he wants to remain at the Allianz Arena despite links with a return to the Premier League next year. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Serie A powerhouses Napoli have supposedly expressed an interest in signing Manchester United defender Harry Maguire on a free transfer next summer. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Alexander Sorloth scored a last-gasp winner as Atletico Madrid defeated Barcelona 2-1 at Estadi Olimpic Lluis Companys to go top of the La Liga table. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Arsenal attacker Bukayo Saka has been seen leaving Selhurst Park on crutches after sustaining a suspected hamstring problem in Saturday's 5-1 Premier League win over Crystal Palace. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Arsenal have written a new page of English football history thanks to their 5-1 destruction of London rivals Crystal Palace in Saturday's Premier League derby. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Round 17 of the 2024-25 Turkish Super Lig will be wrapped up with a clash between two sides from the Marmara region, as Istanbul Basaksehir welcome Kasimpasa to the Basaksehir Fatih Terim Stadyumu on Monday evening. 21 December 2024 talksport.com Leicester loan star Facundo Buonanotte wants to see a Tottenham forward join him so they can rekindle their partnership. 21 December 2024 talksport.com Arsenal's rivals will hate it but they can definitely claim London is red after their 5-1 win over Crystal Palace. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Arsenal striker Gabriel Jesus continued his resurgence with two goals as the Gunners demolished Crystal Palace 5-1 in the Premier League at Selhurst Park. 21 December 2024 talksport.com Arsenal fans' worst fears have been realised with Bukayo Saka substituted early with a suspected hamstring injury. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Arsenal have suffered a worrying injury blow over Bukayo Saka, who appeared to pick up a hamstring problem in Saturday's Premier League clash with Crystal Palace. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Barcelona and Arsenal are reportedly both interested in signing Sevilla midfielder Lucien Agoume, with the France Under-21s international potentially leaving Estadio Ramon next summer. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Real Madrid have welcomed Ferland Mendy back into their squad for Sunday's La Liga clash with Sevilla. 21 December 2024 talksport.com Mykhailo Mudryk will be sat ringside at Oleksandr Usyk's rematch with Tyson Fury days after being suspended from football. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Southampton have confirmed the appointment of former Roma head coach Ivan Juric as their new manager following the departure of Russell Martin. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Newcastle United's 4-0 victory against Ipswich Town on Saturday afternoon at Portman Road ensured that they followed up their qualification for the EFL Cup semi-final with an important three points in the Premier League. 21 December 2024 talksport.com Southampton have confirmed ex-Roma boss Ivan Juric as their new manager to replace Russell Martin. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Nottingham Forest enhanced their Champions League credentials and condemned Brentford to their first home loss of the Premier League season with a 2-0 victory at the Gtech Community Stadium. 21 December 2024 talksport.com Jack Grealish burned some bridges with Aston Villa after taunting the club's fans following their victory over Manchester City. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk A fitting final Premier League match before Christmas Day, Tottenham Hotspur and Liverpool engage in a battle of the behemoths in North London on Sunday afternoon. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Aston Villa handed Manchester City a 2-1 defeat on Saturday, adding to the woes of Pep Guardiola's side, who have now endured nine losses in their last 12 matches. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Aston Villa head coach Unai Emery has claimed that his side decided to defeat Manchester City "through domination" on Saturday afternoon. 21 December 2024 talksport.com "This is a crisis." 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Real Madrid will be bidding to return to winning ways in La Liga when they welcome Sevilla to Bernabeu on Sunday. 21 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Real Madrid have added Liverpool captain Virgil van Dijk to their wishlist for the summer transfer window, according to a report.