The British boxer - who played for the Rest of the World in their 4-2 win against England - came on in the 21st minute for comedian Maisie Adam and made an immediate impact for all the wrong reasons.
He was guilty of a wayward shot that went high into the crowd after being picked out by Manchester United cult hero Nani inside the box.
The Love Island star also failed to control the ball before attempting to pull off an audacious back-heel that went nowhere.
And he then tried another showboat pass, which again led to nothing.
Italian World Cup winner Francesco Totti regularly looked to play in the 24-year-old, who showed he is clearly better with his hands than he is with his feet.
READ MORE ON SOCCER AID
Usain Bolt opens scoring in Soccer Aid as he pulls off Marcus Rashford's celebration
Ben Foster delivers sly dig to Danny Dyer midway through live interview on pitch
His performance led to a huge reaction on social media, with some comparing him to Romelu Lukaku, who had a nightmare game against Manchester City in the Champions League final.
The Belgian missed a glorious chance to equalise as well as getting in the way of Federico Dimarco's goal-bound header.
One fan tweeted: "Trying to work out who's worse at football. Tommy Fury or Romelu Lukaku."
Another posted: "Tommy Fury bringing the heat with his football skills, channeling the power of Romelu Lukaku on the field!"
Most read in Football
Man United transfer news LIVE: Maguire wants to stay, Greenwood loan eyed, Kane latest
Grealish seen in full kit at 7.30am as Man City stars refuse to end Champions League party
Foster reveals special conditions that led to Wrexham deal with Reynolds and McElhenney
Newcastle given Maguire ultimatum by Man United despite different Aston Villa stance
A third added: "Tommy Fury has been honking on #SoccerAid. Still doing better than Lukaku last night though."
Even talkSPORT's very own Mark Goldbridge got involved, as he quipped: "Still rather Tommy Fury playing up front for Inter last night instead of Lukaku."
Managing the World XI, Pochettino clearly had seen enough as he hauled Fury off at half-time.