Indonesia
Nigeria
South Africa

Roy Keane's assessment on 14 Man Utd stars from Cristiano Ronaldo to Paul Pogba

mirror.co.uk, 18 December 2021, 09:00
Manchester United legend Roy Keane isn't one to hold back when airing his views on players and those at his former club seem to receive more brutally honest assessments than most

To say it has been an eventful season so far at Manchester United would be an understatement.

From the euphoria surrounding the sensational deadline day return of Cristiano Ronaldo to Ole Gunnar Solskjaer no longer finding himself at the wheel, it's been quite the ride.

Humiliation at the hands of fierce rivals Liverpool and Manchester City were the lowest points in a topsy-turvy season so far which has also seen Ronaldo rescuing United with a number of dramatic late goals.

The Red Devils have constantly hogged the headlines in recent months with several of their former players turned pundits speaking up, but perhaps the most vocal of all has been that of United's often-outspoken ex-captain Roy Keane.

The football hardman hasn't held back as he's blasted the squad on countless occasions for invariably failing to show the same passionate and aggression that he did back in the day.

From Cristiano Ronaldo to Paul Pogba, Mirror Football takes a look back over the often scathing assessments Keane has offered up on United's stars in recent years.

What has been Roy Keane's most iconic Manchester United rant so far this season? Let us know in the comments below!

De Gea against Manchester City (November 2021)

"Just on half time, a huge goal against City dominating possession but this defending from Shaw and De Gea, there's not enough pressure.

"You have to show intensity and put pressure on. You're on the ropes to stay in the game. You're like a boxer - stay in the game!

"I've been crossing these fellas for years - I give up. I give up on these players. These are international players, I give up. I can't understand the defending. I give up.

"I drove up thinking United have a chance, but unless they do something drastic it will be another four or five."

On Shaw and Maguire (October 2021)

"But individual performances… Maguire and Shaw last week, they were a disgrace. An absolute disgrace to the club. And these are established international footballers.

"I heard Maguire talking during the week. He was like a robot. He was like, 'Apologies to the fans…' There was no emotion behind it.

"And these guys are on the back of good European Championships for England. They have turned up before for big matches. But recently… and Shaw has fallen back into his old habits a few years ago.

"I'm fed up with his chat after games with people apologising. Harry Maguire talking about 'we need to come together as a group'. No, you need to sort your game out.

"If you're going to be the leader of that group then you need to get the basics right. You need to do your own job."

On Maguire's response to his critics (November 2021)

"Maguire puts his hands to his ears like he's shutting his critics up... it's embarrassing.

"He's been a disgrace last few months for Manchester United, he scores and he thinks he's going to shut his critics up, it's embarrassing."

On Wan-Bissaka after the Liverpool loss (October 2021)

"Wan-Bissaka - I don't even think Palace would take him back now. He's not good enough for Manchester United.

"No feel for the ball. No decision making.

"What Manchester United have always had over the years, no matter talented players, is players with character and personalities. I don't see it with this group."

Pogba's lack of leadership (May 2021)

"Again, I look back and think Man United should be competing in the Champions League, but I still don't think Pogba will drive Man United back to winning championships.

"I don't think he's a big leader, I don't think he's that type of character.

"He's done better the last few games and obviously he did well during the week against Roma - although I thought the standard of that game was really poor.

"I still think Man United need to go out and get two world-class players and of course it's easier said than done."

On the midfield of Fred, McTominay and Matic (August 2021)

"I don't want to mention Fred again because I seem to be on his case all the time.

"I think if you want to play for a big team in midfield you've got to hang your hat on something to say well, 'you're brilliant at going forward, or brilliant defensively or he's got a goal in him' - I don't see any of them in Fred.

"I think Scott McTominay has got a chance of being a player, Matic... would any of these players get in the Man City team or Liverpool? Or Chelsea? I don't see it."

On Rashford and Greenwood's England issues (November 2021)

"I know they've had injuries, I understand that, but we know their quality and when Gareth is asked about them he says 'yeah I spoke to Marcus...' It seems like a big conversation.

"It's as if there's something going wrong, there's something amiss with some of these United lads.

"They're young and hungry but a change of scenery will probably do them the world of good, there's negativity around United at the moment with the bad results.

"There's this idea that they need to save their club and do something about it on the training pitch there."

Lingard's move not materialising (September 2021)

"I don't think Lingard is going to get Man Utd challenging for titles.

"Jesse has done well at West Ham and maybe they're a good fit for him. But if you're asking me do I think Lingard will get Man Utd winning titles, the answer is no.

"That's the exact words I would use - no man's land.

"It's been difficult, you thought he'd get a move. But he's got to get his head down at Man United."

Fernandes' failures against City last season (January 2021)

"It's not easy. Not easy winning football trophies.

"You know Fernandes has had great praise and over the past few months, people have been comparing him to Eric Cantona etc. but Fernandes didn't really do much tonight.

"The top players turn up on the big occasions. That's what Cantona used to do, [they] get their hands-on trophies. And that's where this team is a little bit short.

"They probably need to have one or two more players come into the squad no doubt and the mentality, maybe they need the confidence of winning a semi-final to get them over the line. Then you get momentum."

On Sancho's slow start (October 2021)

"It's certainly been a slow start for him, it's well and good doing well at Dortmund but it's a different animal going to Man United, big expectations.

"He's maybe been overshadowed slightly with Ronaldo coming in but I'd always give the kid a chance, he's been there a few months, nice opportunity for him tonight but give him a chance."

His Ronaldo rant before clashing with Carragher (November 2021)

"Ronaldo has not come back to Manchester United to sit on the bench.

"His stats since he came back to the club are ok - he has got some goals and some assists.

"This idea that he is going to start closing people down? He's not.

"He's a world class player, the idea Ronaldo will close people down he's not. But sometimes you have to work around the superstar.

"I've played with players who don't do the bit you hope - the Cantonas of this world - but you forgive them because they score the winning goals in tight matches."

Top News

14 January 2025 talksport.com Manchester City are back throwing around the big bucks in an attempt to save their season. 14 January 2025 talksport.com Manchester United host Southampton at Old Trafford on Thursday night aiming to build on their impressive recent results. 14 January 2025 talksport.com Nottingham Forest will be looking to bring themselves right into title contention tonight when they host Liverpool. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Club legend Pat Nevin has suggested that Chelsea's business model will be labelled a failure unless they qualify for next season's Champions League. 14 January 2025 talksport.com Troy Deeney loves Newcastle, regardless of what is being said about him. 14 January 2025 talksport.com Arsenal defender Oleksandr Zinchenko is wanted by Borussia Dortmund, talkSPORT understands. 14 January 2025 talksport.com Emma Raducanu booked her place in the Australian Open second round despite difficulties with her serve. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk De Graafschap and Heracles will be targeting a place in the KNVB Beker quarter-finals when they square off on Thursday night. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Manchester City expert Steven McInerney from Esteemed Kompany has told Sports Mole that he expects wantaway defender Kyle Walker to leave the club during the January transfer window. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Leicester City are reportedly willing to sell defender Wout Faes in the January transfer window. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Bayern Munich director Christopher Freund has suggested that they would prefer to retain the services of Mathys Tel. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta refused to confirm reports that Gabriel Jesus had suffered an ACL injury, but the Gunners boss admitted once again that he is "very worried" about the Brazilian. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Liverpool have reportedly rejected a lucrative offer for the signature of Darwin Nunez. 14 January 2025 talksport.com Arsenal are looking to reignite their long-term interest in Dusan Vlahovic, talkSPORT understands. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Chelsea are reportedly open to parting ways with Axel Disasi before the end of the January transfer window. 14 January 2025 talksport.com Josh Keeley is one win away from facing the best goalscorer in England, Erling Haaland, having proven a dab hand at finding the net himself. 14 January 2025 talksport.com Nuno Espirito Santo should be named Manager of the year if Nottingham Forest qualify for the Champions League. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Arsenal striker Gabriel Jesus has suffered a suspected anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tear and is likely to miss the rest of the season, according to a report. 14 January 2025 talksport.com Gabriel Jesus is facing another lengthy spell on the sidelines to deal Arsenal a major injury blow. 14 January 2025 talksport.com Chelsea like to remind London rivals Tottenham let Willian slip through their grasp. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Trent Alexander-Arnold has at least temporarily silenced those who criticised him and suggested he is not committed to Liverpool, Reds expert David Lynch has argued. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Rio Ngumoha demonstrated why he has a bright future at Liverpool when Arne Slot's side beat Accrington Stanley 4-0 in the FA Cup last Saturday, according to Reds expert David Lynch 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk The transfer window is open! Clubs around the UK and Europe have one final chance to strengthen their squads for the second half of the season. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk array(0) {} 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Holstein Kiel vs. Dortmund (Tuesday, 5.30pm) Under-pressure boss Nuri Sahin needs his Borussia Dortmund side to beat Holstein Kiel in the Bundesliga on Tuesday when they travel to Holstein-Stadion. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Como vs. AC Milan (Tuesday, 5.30pm) Playing catch-up in the race for a top-four finish, AC Milan will seek their first Serie A win of the year when they make the short trip to Como on Tuesday. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Brentford vs. Man City (Tuesday, 7.30pm) Kicking off a three-game road trip in the English capital, a revitalised Manchester City seek a fourth win on the spin in Tuesday's Premier League clash with Brentford at the Gtech Community Stadium. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Paris Saint-Germain have reportedly reached an agreement to sign Napoli winger Khvicha Kvaratskhelia, who has been linked with Liverpool and Manchester United. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk Chelsea have reportedly made contact with Bayern Munich over a potential deal for forward Mathys Tel. 14 January 2025 sportsmole.co.uk RKC Waalwijk and FC Utrecht will battle it out for a quarter-final berth in the 2024-25 KNVB Beker when they go head to head at the Mandemakers Stadion on Wednesday.