Croatia
Indonesia
Nigeria
South Africa

Moyes vetoed Thiago transfer for Fellaini, but Man Utd admit fault for Scot's struggles

talksport.com, 6 January 2022, 14:30
David Moyes turned down the chance to sign Thiago Alcantara for Manchester United, opting for Marouane Fellaini instead.

However, talkSPORT understands the Premier League giants now acknowledge it was their fault the current West Ham manager wasn't a success at Old Trafford.

This is one of the many shock revelations to emerge following news of Ed Woodward's imminent departure as executive vice-chairman at Old Trafford.

The Red Devils struggled on the pitch in their first season following the departure of legendary boss Ferguson.

And it appears there were as many issues off the pitch as there were on it, with 'power struggles' between managers and the recruitment department seeing big Man United signings fail to come off.

talkSPORT host Jim White revealed in his first summer at Old Trafford, Moyes vetoed a move for a then 22-year-old Barcelona midfielder Thiago, who ended up moving to Bayern Munich.

The Red Devils then forked out just shy of £30million to bring in Fellaini - the Belgium following Moyes to Old Trafford from Everton.

Well, we know how that ended. While he did have his moments, Fellaini is widely considered a flop at United despite lifting the FA Cup, Carabao Cup and Europa League under Mourinho.

Thiago, a four-time LaLiga champion with Barcelona, moved to Germany and went on to win a stunning seven consecutive Bundesliga titles with Bayern, plus the Champions League crown, and now plays for arch rivals Liverpool.

"It's our understanding that in the early years, post-Sir Alex, part of the issues with recruitment at United was down to veto power struggles between managers and the recruitment department," said the White and Jordan host.

"Let me give you two examples. Under David Moyes, the recruitment department lined up Thiago Alcantara, now of Liverpool.

"But the club ended up with Marouane Fellaini due to the manager's veto."

White added that Jose Mourinho, who is understood to have turned down the chance to re-sign Cristiano Ronaldo in 2018, encountered a similar problem when trying to push the club to sign a defender that summer, but was told 'no' to his No.1 target.

It is believed the correct procedures are in place now but, according to a club source, more could've been done to help Moyes be a success at Man United.

"Sources inside the football club have told me that they didn't give Moyes the right structure to be successful," said White.

"They believe it was their fault and not his.

"They believe it was the wrong time for Moyes to come to the football club. All these years later they're saying it was them who let Moyes down, and not Moyes letting United down."

But Simon Jordan believes the Fellaini signing shows that the Scot didn't always help himself.

"If you compare Moyes with other managers then that argument holds water," said the former Crystal Palace owner.

"Did they let him down on recruitment? Well, if they offered him Thiago and he chose Fellaini, then you've got to ask who let who down.

"Where they did let him down… you don't run a business based on what the media tell you, you run a business on the back of what you see and what you know to be the case and what you believe are the reasons why you employed somebody. When you fire somebody, there's no winner, everyone fails.

"David Moyes walked into a nigh on impossible situation because it's universally accepted that the squad that won the title in 2013 were in the knackers yard and there was a need to rebuild the team.

"And the oracle Sir Alex Ferguson worked and it was unbelievable to get them to win the title.

"They bottled it. The guy wasn't particularly doing anything wrong but there was always going to be a backlash because he wasn't Sir Alex Ferguson.

"David Moyes can feel let down, but I don't think he helped himself either."

Top News

23 December 2024 talksport.com Michael Owen has slammed the Aston Villa supporters who booed Jack Grealish - and told them to 'hang your heads in shame'. 23 December 2024 talksport.com Former Manchester City star Jesus Navas couldn't hold back the tears as he was given an emotional send-off before his retirement. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta has confirmed that he expects Bukayo Saka to be out for "many weeks" with the hamstring injury he suffered in Saturday's 5-1 Premier League win over Crystal Palace. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Chelsea are reportedly struggling to attract offers for one of their fringe players ahead of the January transfer window. 23 December 2024 talksport.com Gareth Southgate had an Adele hit on repeat before stepping down as England manager. 23 December 2024 talksport.com Arsenal star Bukayo Saka is set to be ruled out until February, talkSPORT understands. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Chelsea have reportedly identified a Sporting Lisbon youngster as a potential signing for Strasbourg. 23 December 2024 talksport.com Big things were expected of Marko Mitrovic when he joined Chelsea as a 16-year-old in 2008. 23 December 2024 talksport.com talkSPORT has today announced that is has won radio rights to the UEFA Women's Euro 2025 coverage. 23 December 2024 talksport.com Boxing Day football is beloved by fans and one of the highlights of the Christmas schedule - but it can prove tricky for the players. 23 December 2024 talksport.com A handful of Premier League stars will be able to spend Christmas at home this year after receiving a Boxing Day ban. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Chelsea return to action on Boxing Day when they play host to local rivals Fulham at Stamford Bridge. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Lisandro Martinez has claimed that Manchester United were "playing so well" before losing 3-0 to Bournemouth on Sunday. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Manchester United head coach Ruben Amorim has allegedly made a further two senior players available for transfer. 23 December 2024 talksport.com Arsenal have reportedly scouted Atalanta striker Mateo Retegui as an alternative transfer target to Alexander Isak and Viktor Gyokeres. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Liverpool have reportedly discovered the asking price of Brighton & Hove Albion forward Joao Pedro. 23 December 2024 talksport.com Denis Suarez wasn't the player Arsenal fans wanted to sign - but he's the footballer supporters have a hard time in forgetting. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Manchester City will be aiming to avoid four straight defeats across all competitions when they welcome Everton to the Etihad in the Premier League on Boxing Day. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk After spending Christmas Day in the bottom half of the Premier League table, Tottenham Hotspur endeavour to atone for recent failings when they travel to Nottingham Forest for a Boxing Day battle. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk After celebrating Christmas Day at the top of the Premier League table, Liverpool get back to business on Boxing Day, when they welcome Leicester City to Anfield. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk The January transfer window is almost here and clubs around the UK and Europe are lining up moves as they look to take advantage of the opportunity to strengthen. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Hatayspor vs. Adana Demirspor (Monday, 5.00pm) The battle of the bottom feeders in the Turkish Super Lig unfolds on Monday as Hatayspor host Adana Demirspor at the Mersin Stadyumu. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Benfica vs. Estoril (Monday, 6.45pm) Separated by 10 places in the Primeira Liga table before gameweek 15, second-placed Benfica are clear favourites to outdo Estoril Praia at Estadio da Luz on Monday. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Fiorentina vs. Udinese (Monday, 5.30pm) After their incredible success streak was finally brought to an end last week, Fiorentina will aim to start another winning run on Monday, when they meet Udinese. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Yemen and Saudi Arabia will celebrate Christmas Day by facing each other on matchday two of the Arabian Gulf Cup on Wednesday at Jaber Al-Ahmad International Stadium in Kuwait City. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Yemen and Saudi Arabia will celebrate Christmas Day by facing each other on matchday two of the Arabian Gulf Cup on Wednesday at Jaber Al-Ahmad International Stadium in Kuwait City. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk First place in Group B of the Arabian Gulf Cup will be at stake on Wednesday as Bahrain and Iraq celebrate Christmas Day at Jaber Al-Ahmad International Stadium in Kuwait. 23 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Manchester United transfer target Randal Kolo Muani is very likely to leave Paris Saint-Germain in the January transfer window, according to reports. 22 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Manchester City have reportedly set their sights on West Ham United attacker Mohammed Kudus, with Pep Guardiola keen to strengthen his struggling squad. 22 December 2024 sportsmole.co.uk Manchester United are reportedly set to rival Arsenal for the signature of Juventus striker Dusan Vlahovic in the summer of 2025.