The Crystal Palace defender appeared to have written on the rainbow-coloured captain's armband against Newcastle, but talkSPORT understands he escaped any FA punishment for the move.
Now, despite the warning that religious messaging is banned, Guehi has opted to hand write a message on the band once again.
This time, he's written on his rainbow armband for his side's clash against Ipswich Town at Portman Road on Tuesday evening with the message: "Jesus loves you."
His writing was followed by a smiley face.
This comes after Guehi, whose father is a church minister, wrote 'I love Jesus' on his armband for Palace's previous outing.
more on the premier league
Marc Guehi escapes FA charge after breaking strict rule with armband message
Major Gyokeres update, Spurs risk losing star player, Walker could join Championship club
All Premier League clubs were given a special rainbow armband for their captains to wear to promote Stonewall's Rainbow Laces campaign which shows support for LGBTQ+ inclusion in sport.
According to the International Football Association Board (IFAB), 'initiative slogans/emblems promoting the game of football, respect and integrity' are permitted.
But it is forbidden to have 'political, religious or personal slogans, statements or images' written anywhere.
The FA's kit and advertising rules do not allow players to wear items of clothing that promote political or religious messaging, either.
Most read in Football
I couldn't stand arrogant Ibrahimovic and our fight forced him to leave club within days
Major Gyokeres update, Spurs risk losing star player, Walker could join Championship club
Klopp could hand Ten Hag new job and break heart of prodigy he 'trusts with everything'
I helped knock Man United's nose out of joint in peak Premier League rivalry with Arsenal
The Tractor Boys captain, Sam Morsy, also made headlines after opting not to wear the armband.
He wore the usual Premier League armband in the 1-0 loss to Nottingham Forest instead.
Morsy, who is capped four times by Egypt, is a practising Muslim.
He's also refused to wear the Stonewall band again against Palace.
"Ipswich Town Football Club is committed to being a fully inclusive club that welcomes everyone," an Ipswich statement released on Monday read.
"At the same time, we respect the decision of our captain Sam Morsy, who has chosen not to wear the rainbow captain's armband due to his religious beliefs.
Crystal Palace fan HOPES his side get relegated so they can win more games after a poor start to the Premier League season
"We will continue to grow an environment where all are valued and respected, both on and off the pitch."
Last season, Sheffield United's Anel Ahmedhodzic elected to wear the regular captain's armband during the Blades' loss to Liverpool instead of a rainbow one.