The 24-year-old had just fired the Gunners into a 2-0 lead over their MLS counterparts after a dazzling performance in the touch challenge.
But the £65million signing from Chelsea was guilty of a horror display in the next event, where he created history by failing to score a single goal - the first time that has happened in this drill since its revamp in 2018.
In this challenge, the shooter receives passes from two of his teammates, where he can decide to take a touch and shoot, or hit a first-time volley for extra points.
Havertz was first up for Arsenal, where he was given 60 seconds to try and better Christian Benteke's tally of 30.
However, to say he struggled would be an understatement, as he barely threatened goalkeeper Roman Burki.
READ MORE ON ARSENAL
Folarin Balogun outshined by Jurrien Timber and Jakub Kiwior in shooting challenge
Arsenal transfer news LIVE: Arteta hints at more business, Inter set to move for Balogun
His last strike on the buzzer smashed against the post, with Havertz walking away with a wry smile at failing to find the back of the net.
Folarin Balogun was next up for Arsenal - scoring three goals - but it wasn't enough, as Denis Bouanga's 95-point tally secured the win for the MLS team.
Social media was left in disbelief by Havertz's performance, with one Arsenal supporter tweeting: "Please put Havertz in midfield."
Another posted: "Havertz was awful in that challenge."
Most read in Football
Onana to Man United, Rashford new deal while Evans re-signs, Chelsea fail in Caicedo bid
Joao Felix channels inner Romelu Lukaku by sending come and get me plea to Barcelona
Rangers 1-2 Newcastle LIVE: Ashby wins it late for Magpies as Howe's men seal victory
Three Bayern stars, including Musiala, score five goals as no mercy shown to local team
A third added: "Arteta better watch this. Havertz is no striker."
This user joked: "We want our money back from Chelsea."
Meanwhile one fan simply stated: "We are in trouble."
Another said: "Keep Havertz away from the box!"
Havertz, who is in line to start against the MLS All-Stars on Thursday, will be hoping to silence his critics with the German in line to start.